DTA bypassed procurement rules to create digital marketplace

Panel could be more "robust".

Australia's national auditor has told the Digital Transformation Agency to improve its procurement practices after basic Commonwealth Procurement Rules (CPRs) were bypassed to establish the Digital Marketplace.

The Digital Marketplace is an open platform designed to bring government buyers and digital sellers together. In an audit of three IT procurement arrangements released on Monday, the Australian National Audit Office said the DTA could not “fully demonstrate” the marketplace “supported the achievement of value for money outcomes”.

It put this down to “planning deficiencies” when the interim Digital Marketplace was created in August 2016, with the DTA failing to reference value for money assessments or any requirement that potential suppliers provide price information in its request for proposal.

“DTA’s planning and approach to market for the establishment of its Digital Marketplace panel did not comply with all of the CPR requirements but did demonstrate the adoption of a number of key sound practices identified in Finance guidance,” the report [pdf] states.

The issue appears to have originated from what can only be described as confusion over what constitutes a procurement, with the DTA’s own planning documents specifying that the process to establish the panel was not deemed to be a procurement.

The DTA instead considered that a procurement would only be completed “when an entity approached the Digital Marketplace with an opportunity and suppliers responded” - a definition that more closely resembles a multi-use list (MUL).

“Nonetheless, DTA thought of the Digital Marketplace as a panel ... without it meeting the requirements of a panel,” the report states.

“In effect, DTA had created a list of prequalified suppliers or a multi-use list rather than a panel and this impacted DTA’s approach to market … and the evaluation of suppliers.”

MULs, which are now defunct, were lists of suppliers who had applied for inclusion on the list and satisfied a set of conditions, however were not the result of a procurement process and involved no value for money assessment like for a panel.

The audit also notes that there was no “probity plan, risk management plan or tender evaluation plan in place prior to establishing the Digital Marketplace panel in February 2017”.

The ANAO said the DTA rectified the issue of CPR non-compliance in 2018, when it refreshed the Digital Marketplace and introduced a new requirement to provide information on price and referencing the need to conduct a value for money assessment.

But when it did so, some IT suppliers such as those on the Australian Taxation Office’s IT MUL - which were offered the option to transfer when MULs ceased in 2018 - were “able to join the Digital Marketplace panel without a value for money assessment”.

This meant that the “DTA did not treat all potential suppliers equitably, as required by the CPRs, as suppliers were able to join the panel via different means”, something that the audit says has continued.

“While DTA’s new process is sufficient to achieve compliance with the minimum requirements of the CPRs, DTA’s consideration of price, quality and risk could be more robust to better demonstrate that its evaluation of suppliers achieves value for money outcomes,” the audit notes.

The ANAO has recommended the DTA ensure that "suppliers are treated equitably and are appointed on the basis of a value for money assessment" when establishing any future procurement panels.

It has also told DTA to school officials undertaking complex procurements to ensure they have "sufficient understanding of the procurement requirements, the nature of the arrangement being established and procurement related risks".

The DTA has agreed to both recommendations.

Risking value for money, competition

The audit also raised concerns with aspects of the Digital Marketplace construct, including only providing government buyers with a “summary of the range of daily rates sellers have been awarded for roles in each category”.

“Buyers do not get to see the approved maximum prices of individual suppliers but can ask DTA to provide this information,” the audit states.

“This means that buyers who do not ask DTA for the specific price information can only use the summary of daily rates on the Digital Marketplace to guide their decision-making regarding which panelists to approach.”

There is also no requirement for Digital Marketplace buyers to “obtain more than one quote for services, which has the potential to reduce competition”.

Data provided by the DTA showed that “the number of approaches made to one supplier was as high as 61 percent for [the Department of] Home Affairs” and “as low as 3.4 percent for DTA”.

“Approaching only one supplier eliminates competition and reduces the ability of entities to demonstrate the achievement of value for money,” the audit states. 

“Approximately 67 percent of all approaches made to suppliers by the audited entities was to five or more suppliers, and DTA approached all suppliers on the Marketplace 90 percent of the time - a much higher percentage than the other entities.”

Other panels

The other two panels assessed as part of the audit included the $1 billion whole-of-government IBM arrangement, which is also owned by the DTA.

While the DTA was found to have “largely complied with the requirements of the CPRs ... and supported the achievement of a value for money outcome”, it didn’t get off scot-free.

The ANAO said the DTA initially treated the “process as a ‘project to establish a contractual framework’ rather than a procurement”.

“As a result, some processes usually adopted for a procurement of this size and scope, such as first for purpose management and probability arrangements, were lacking,” the report states.

It also noted that the DTA “lacked capability in terms of engaging effectively with IBM in negotiations”, which the DTA put down to a “lack of understanding of IBM’s business structure”.

The report also looked at the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Communications’s IT service panel, which expired in February 2020.

The audit found the department complied with the CPRs and adopted related guidance when it established its IT services panel.

However, it could have “adopted a more robust approach to the consolidation of price, quality and risk”, leading the audit to conclude that it “could not fully demonstrate the arrangements supported the achievement of value for money outcomes”.

“Had Infrastructure established stronger thresholds in terms of price, quality and risk and included details in the request documentation, it would be have been in a better position to undertake a more robust assessment of value for money at the evaluation stage,” the report said.

FOR ANY DIGITAL MARKETING SERVICES CONTACT OUR TEAM TODAY TO HELP. info@Vissicon.com #cybersecurity #hacking #security #technology #hacker #infosec #tech #ethicalhacking #programming #linux #hackers #cyber #kalilinux #cybercrime #malware #python #privacy #it #iot #cyberattack #coding #dataprotection #hack #ethicalhacker #networking #informationsecurity #cybersecurityawareness #programmer #datasecurity #itsecurity #informationtechnology #software #business #cloud #computerscience #computer #internet #cloudcomputing #network #windows #bhfyp #data #phishing #hacked #cybersecuritytraining #coder #ai #artificialintelligence #cisco #anonymous #code #ransomware #encryption #networksecurity #java #digital #training #bigdata #machinelearning

Originally published : https://www.itnews.com.au

0 views0 comments
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
927 Beaufort Street, Mt Lawley,
Perth 6052
836/585 Little Collins Street,
Melbourne, 3000

Digital Marketing Agency Perth - Perth Digital Agency at your service. If you want your business to dominate the online world, you need to align yourself with a digital marketing agency that is not just following the latest trends but also creating them. Perth Digital Marketing is ridiculously competitive, so if you want your business to do more than just survive, you need to choose a marketing agency that is going to offer both proven strategies and outside the box thinking. At Vissi, we pride ourselves in offering revolutionary and proven strategies to help your business thrive and grow in the competitive online market. We work alongside your business every step of the way and ensure that you have the right tools you need to increase your profits and maximise your investment. We are experts in helping your business to find an endless line of customers that are ready and willing to spend on your products and services, using our clever and unrivalled marketing and conversion techniques. These techniques work almost instantly, which means that you don’t have to wait years to see growth or profits flowing in. In fact, most of the businesses that we work with begin to achieve their desired results in just a few months. How do we do it? It is our unwavering approach, dedication and out of the box thinking that has made us one of the premier digital agencies Perth. So, when it comes to selecting a digital marketing agency that is going to propel your business to new heights, don’t just take our word for it. Why not contact us today and see what we can do to help your business? Digital Marketing in Perth - Vissi started from humble beginnings in Perth and has quickly grown to become one of the top digital marketing agencies in the Perth digital agency scene.  Located in the Perth CBD, our digital agency caters to businesses both big and small in all areas of the city and beyond. By growing our business from the ground up in Perth, we know exactly what it takes to appeal to local audiences and how to navigate through the ever-evolving culture and economy of the city. We also pride ourselves on being able to offer Perth business owners some of the top proven marketing strategies that are breaking ground locally and all over the world. These strategies including helping your business to rank higher in search results and turning your traffic into leads that actually convert into paying customers.  In fact, we have helped brands increase profits by nearly ten times as much, all by following some of our proven methods. Whether you are a brick and mortar business or based solely online, Vissi is dedicated to helping you grow your business into a thriving profit machine, so you can spend more time doing the things you love and less time worrying about your business.

Perth Digital Marketing - Even though Vissi first started in Perth, we are quickly developing an extensive database of clients across Western Australia. We have worked with some of the biggest brands based out of Perth and have a strong track record in the area. But really, working with Vissi is super easy no matter where you live. We have a dedicated team that will help you every step of the way and ensure that your business is set up not just for short-term results, but for long-term success as well. After just a few short months of working with us, you will start to see your business growing rapidly. Your conversion rates will be up; your sales will be up, and of course, your profits will also be up. Guaranteed. Vissi is also one of the only digital marketing agencies out there that offer guaranteed results. We don’t do this as a desperate sales tactic, we do this because we stand by what we do 100%. Real Estate Digital Marketing - Digital Marketing for Real Estate Agents - Perth Digital Agency - Digital Marketing Agency Perth - Web Design Perth - Perth Web Design - SEO Agency Perth - SEO Perth - SEO in Perth - Perth SEO Agency - Perth web design - Ecommerce web design Perth - IT support Perth - IT Services Perth - Managed IT Perth  - Perth hosting – Busselton Digital Agency – South West Digital Agency – Digital Agency in Busselton

© 2020 Vissi Digital. Proudly designed and developed by Vissi Digital. Please review our TERMS & CONDITIONS and PRIVACY POLICY.